Why Batman Won’t Appear In James Gunn’s New R-Rated Horror Despite Comic Book Feud Explained


The DC Universe will soon be taking a visit to Gotham City as James Gunn’s franchise continues to expand.

The DCU’s Chapter 1: “Gods and Monsters” slate is going forward with numerous movies and TV shows building out Gunn’s superhero reboot. Following Supergirl this summer, the next theatrical release will be a vastly darker adventure for DC Studios in the fall.

In a new interview with Entertainment Weekly, Clayface director James Watkins finally addressed why Batman won’t be showing up in the R-rated installment. The filmmaker stated, “The story is Clayface’s story, it’s Matt Hagen’s story. If you just took one person within the world of Gotham and followed their story, it’s about following the integrity of that. You don’t necessarily bump into any of these people…It’s just one big city. I can see why people worry about these things, but that’s not my job. My job is to worry about, Is this story honest to itself? and not try to think of ways to be cute, I suppose.”

Naomi Ackie, who plays Dr. Caitlyn Corr, joked about how “we were joking that we could go and get Rob to do a little cameo for us. But he was busy being Batman, saving another Gotham.” According to the Clayface star, she had imagined it would be “through a window, you see Rob in his full gear. That’s what we were thinking.”

Given that The Brave and The Bold movie is still in development, it wouldn’t make sense to have the DCU’s Caped Crusader show up in Clayface, especially as casting won’t happen until the script for Bruce Wayne’s reboot is actually completed. To this point, Batman has only appeared through animated silent cameos in DC Studios’ Creature Commandos.

In the same interview with EW, The Batman’s Matt Reeves, who produced the 2026 DCU entry, shared why he wanted to explore another side of the Dark Knight’s mythology, but in Gunn’s continuity. He shared how “I’m drawn to the more grounded DC Comic characters, and coming off The Batman wanted to expand that interest to other characters and stories. Clayface presented a unique opportunity to dive into an origin story within a specific genre — it’s a tragic character journey wrapped in terrifying body horror.”

The Clayface story will explore the origin story of how Matt Hagen, played by Tom Rhys Harries, becomes the iconic shape-shifting mud-monster, with the DCU being the first film franchise to bring the comic book villain to the big screen. DC Studios co-CEO Peter Safran also confirmed that this takes place prior to Creature Commandos, and that it was indeed Matt who showed up in the animated series.

















From the Caped Crusader to The Batman · Eight Questions
How Well Do You Know Batman?
“I’m Batman.”

🦌Bob & BillDetective Comics #27, 1939

🥘The Camp EraAdam West, 1966

🎣Burton & SchumacherKeaton to Clooney, 1989–97

💉The Dark KnightBale & Ledger, 2005–12

🕵The BatmanPattinson & Reeves, 2022–

01

Batman debuted in Detective Comics #27 in May 1939. Cartoonist Bob Kane received sole credit for creating the character for the next 76 years — on every comic, every TV series, every film — despite being only half of the real partnership. His uncredited collaborator wrote much of the original story, designed the cowl and cape, invented the name “Bruce Wayne,” named Gotham City, and helped create the Joker, the Penguin, the Riddler and Catwoman. DC finally added his name to all Batman credits in 2015. Who?




02

Batman: The Movie — released in July 1966 between the first and second seasons of the ABC TV series, featuring the “Holy Whatever, Batman!” tone, the four super-villain team-up (Joker, Penguin, Riddler, Catwoman), the shark-repellent Bat-spray, and the Batmobile/Batboat/Batcopter — is generally considered the first theatrical Batman feature film. Two earlier 1940s movie serials don’t qualify as standalone features. Which actor played Batman in this first theatrical feature?




03

Batman: The Animated Series (Fox Kids, 1992–1995) — the Bruce Timm/Eric Radomski production with the deco-noir “Dark Deco” backgrounds painted on black paper — is consistently ranked by fans and creators as the definitive screen Batman. Its central performance is so iconic that the actor reprised it across 30 years, every DC Animated Universe series, and a dozen Arkham-series video games. He died on November 10, 2022, and DC essentially treated his passing as the death of Batman’s voice. Name him.




04

Jack Nicholson’s Joker in Tim Burton’s Batman (1989) earned him an estimated $60–$90 million from a film for which his actual on-screen salary was a fairly modest $6 million — making it, dollar-for-dollar, one of the most famously lucrative single roles in Hollywood history. He achieved this by negotiating an unusual deal structure that other actors immediately tried (and largely failed) to copy. What was it?




05

After Ben Affleck stepped down from his planned solo Batman film, Warner Bros. handed the project to a new director who reconceived it as a noir-detective serial-killer story modelled on Se7en and Zodiac, runs 2h 56min, casts Robert Pattinson as a brooding second-year Bruce Wayne, and gives Paul Dano’s Riddler a Zodiac-style cipher gimmick. The Batman (2022) grossed $772 million worldwide. Who directed it?




06

Joel Schumacher’s Batman & Robin (1997) — with Bat-nipples on the suit, Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Mr. Freeze spitting ice puns (“Let’s kick some ice!”), Uma Thurman’s Poison Ivy, Alicia Silverstone’s Batgirl, and an estimated $238 million box-office failure on a $125 million budget — is widely regarded as one of the worst superhero films ever made. It killed the live-action Batman franchise for eight years until Batman Begins (2005). Who played Batman in it?




07

Cesar Romero’s Joker on the 1966–1968 ABC Batman series — white grease-paint, green wig, red lipstick, manic giggle — remains one of the most-cited comedic TV villains in American history. Romero, a leading-man matinée idol since the 1930s, agreed to the role on one condition: he refused to do a specific thing for the makeup. You can still see what he refused if you look closely. What did Romero refuse?




08

Todd Phillips’s Joker (2019) — the standalone, R-rated, $1.07-billion-grossing Joaquin Phoenix vehicle that exists outside any DC continuity — was nominated for 11 Academy Awards, the most of any comic-book-derived film at the time. It won Best Actor for Phoenix. It also won exactly one other Oscar that night. Which?




The Bat-Signal Has Faded · Final Scorecard
Your Gotham Standing

🦌

/ 8

World’s Greatest Detective — or a Gotham red herring?

Even though Batman isn’t showing up in Clayface, that doesn’t mean the October feature won’t have fun with the comic book canon. Watkins explained to EW that “There are little Easter eggs for those really in the know, but they’re very light sprinklings, whether it’s name references or occasional background references or visual illusions. If you didn’t know this world, you wouldn’t spot them — and they’re not there to pull people out [of the story].”

Time will tell what Clayface’s future in the DCU looks like after his big-screen debut, as there are numerous directions that they can take with him after his solo story. But as DC Studios gets ready to head to Gotham City in the fall, audience members will hopefully get a better idea of where they are going with him beyond 2026.

Clayface is scheduled to open in theaters on October 23.



Release Date

October 23, 2026

Director

James Watkins

  • Headshot Of Tom Rhys Harries

    Tom Rhys Harries

    Matt Hagen / Clayface

  • Headshot Of Naomi Ackie

    Naomi Ackie

    Dr. Caitlin Bates

  • Headshot Of David Dencik

  • Headshot of Max Minghella




Source link

  • Related Posts

    Avengers: Doomsday Is Finally Giving Us Avengers Vs X-Men

    The MCU has finally confirmed an Avengers vs X-Men skirmish of sorts is on the horizon via Avengers: Doomsday‘s new trailer – but the battle already looks very different to…

    Tiger King’s Spiritual Successor Lands On HBO Max Next Month

    Tiger King‘s spiritual successor is set to debut on HBO Max on August 6, 2026, showcasing another dimension of the weird, unflattering, and often cruel world of the exotic animal…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *