I’ve Changed My Mind, I Don’t Think Below Deck Down Under Season 3 Is Better Than Sailing Yacht Season 5


Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s fifth season left viewers disappointed, and concerns are growing that Below Deck Down Under will follow course. Below Deck Sailing Yacht struggled to perform in the aftermath of a riveting fourth season involving an explosive love triangle between Chief Stew Daisy Kelliher, Chief Engineer Colin Macrae, and First Officer Gary King. Viewers were anxious to see the fallout continue on-screen in season 5, but Colin’s departure from the series left them longing for more. Furthermore, misconduct allegations against Gary cast a dark shadow over his return, and conservative editing resulted in a bland and unsatisfying season.

Following Sailing Yacht’s disappointment, Below Deck Down Under’s return was highly anticipated after its smashing success in season 2. The show previously flourished with the pairing of Captain Jason Chambers and Chief Stew Aesha Scott, tasteful navigation of tricky topics, and the beautiful Australian setting. But season 3 is changing course with a new chief stew and a new location that threatens to disrupt the successful formula of the past. I’m concerned the changes may backfire, and instead of making BDDU season 3 the best, it will pale in comparison to even Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5.

The Cast Members On BDSY Are More Entertaining

The New Down Under Cast Might Not Live Up To Expectations

Although fans were disappointed by Colin’s departure, Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s remaining season 5 cast members made up for his absence. Daisy and Gary’s relationship played out in a more respectful manner than it did in season 4, which I believe helped them move on from their disastrous past. Despite many viewers disagreeing with the decision to keep Gary on the show, it’s undeniable that he drew attention to season 5. The scrutiny over his behavior and attempted redemption arc amplified Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s entertainment value to a new level.

Related


20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now

Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.

Meanwhile, the new BDSY cast members brought their share of drama. Stew Danni Warren was quickly labeled a villain after questioning Daisy’s authority and prioritizing hookups over her job. Danni and Diana Cruz’s dissatisfaction with Daisy’s leadership became a recurring theme throughout season 5, reaching cataclysmic levels by the time filming wrapped. Danni and Diana continued to speak about their frustration with Daisy, while Daisy made speculative comments about Danni’s behavior after the show ended. Although the drama was petty, I’m convinced the feud drew viewers in and kept interest high even after the season’s conclusion.

In contrast, Below Deck Down Under’s new cast has gotten off to a slow start. Aesha’s replacement, Chief Stew Lara Rigby, emerged with few endearing qualities. Lara is painfully strict, and her inflexibility suggests she will have a difficult time balancing her perfectionism with the chaos of filming, especially on a yacht the size of Katina. Lara’s two-faced attitude toward Chef Tzarina Mace-Ralph also didn’t help. I’m positive viewers will be unlikely to side with Lara, making any drama within the interior team feel one-dimensional.

While the remaining new faces on Below Deck Down Under have plenty of potential, none stand out as particularly entertaining as the season begins. The only clear villain so far is Katina and the challenges arising from the yacht’s daunting size and infested kitchen. The crew feels lackluster without an electrifying chief stew like Aesha, and I’m concerned that the new season will never match the pace of Sailing Yacht season 5.

Captain Glenn’s Close Relationship With The Crew Members Is Nice To See

Captain Jason Lacks An Extensive History With His Crew

The differences between Below Deck Down Under’s Captain Jason and Sailing Yacht Captain Glenn Shephard also contribute to the disparity between the shows. Captain Jason, whose third season takes him away from his Australian homeland to the Seychelles, might potentially leave viewers wanting more. His heartthrob status makes him a Below Deck fan favorite, but I believe his good looks alone aren’t enough to keep the season afloat.

He’s worked with Daisy and Gary for years, giving him insight into their strengths and weaknesses.

Captain Glenn acts as both a leader and a mentor to his crew. He’s worked with Daisy and Gary for years, giving him insight into their strengths and weaknesses. Captain Glenn is invested in his crew and their success. While Captain Jason is eager to help aboard the yacht and has no qualms about working alongside his team, his casual attitude and relatively young age make him less of a guiding figure than Captain Glenn.

Although both are exceptional captains, I’m worried Captain Jason will never have as close a relationship with his crew as Captain Glenn. Captain Glenn was a big part of what made Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 bearable. He was strict when necessary and wasn’t afraid to punish the crew for their indiscretions, hoping it would motivate them to do better. Captain Jason may be more inclined to terminate crew members for their mistakes, an attitude that will prevent him from ever forming close relationships.

Below Deck Down Under’s Initial Drama Isn’t As Captivating

Season 3’s Disappointing Start Is A Worrying Sign Of Things To Come

Below Deck Down Under season 3’s drama appears to center around power battles. Chef Tzarina is already clashing with her sous-chef, Anthony Bird, and underutilizes his help. Meanwhile, Lara and Tzarina have their battles with communication despite the two having worked together in the past. Although the drama in the kitchen has the potential to become captivating, so far, it’s simply a matter of the crew settling into their roles, suggesting it won’t be enough to keep audiences engaged.

Lara’s interactions with her stews also have the potential to stir up drama, but the situation doesn’t compare to Daisy’s friction with Danni and Diana in Below Deck Sailing Yacht. As for the exterior team, Deckhand Johnny Arvantis’s assumption of the lead position hints that his ego may create chaos aboard the Katina. But I believe the crew will suffer from the lack of an energetic and charismatic figure like Gary, who, despite his faults, kept things interesting in BDSY.

Below Deck Down Under faces a steep uphill battle in living up to the expectations created by season 2. Its confusing location change and Aesha’s departure have left the new season struggling. Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 had its share of problems, but it struck the perfect balance of continuing the previous season’s drama while introducing fiery new personalities. I’m concerned about the future of Below Deck Down Under, and season 3’s slow start has me rethinking my criticism of Sailing Yacht season 5.

Below Deck Down Under airs on Mondays at 8 p.m. EST on Bravo.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Strange New Worlds’ Final 6-Episode Season Promises Focused Storytelling

    Star Trek: Strange New Worlds‘ short fifth and final season comes with an encouraging silver lining. Paramount+ announced that Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 5 would be the end…

    The Walking Dead Season 1 Characters Ranked from Worst to Best

    Seminal zombie apocalypse thriller The Walking Dead may have a truncated first season, but the show’s first six episodes certainly pack a punch. Even more importantly, they introduce many of…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *